The_Replacement_Effect_is_Wrong.hwp AER's Referee Report.pdf Abstract Reinganum (1983, 1985) suggested the replacement effect. It has been accepted generally. But this common belief is wrong. Gilbert and Newbery (1984) and Yi (1995) say the replacement effect stems from Reinganum model's peculiarity. But Reingaum's replacement effect is only a calculation error. Reinganum considers three cases;..